Compliance Comparison

HireVue vs Pymetrics

Compare compliance requirements for these AI hiring tools under NYC Local Law 144, Colorado AI Act, and other state regulations.

HireVueHigh Risk

Video Interview

AI-powered skill validation platform using video interviews, game-based assessments, and virtual job tryouts. Uses machine learning to analyze communication patterns, behavioral analytics, and role-specific competencies.

AI Features

  • Interview Insights with AI analysis
  • Virtual job tryouts and skill validation
  • Game-based cognitive assessments
  • Structured interview evaluation with NLP
  • Behavioral analytics and competency scoring
  • Automated candidate engagement

Applicable Laws

NYC Local Law 144Illinois AIVIColorado AI ActMaryland HB 1202Texas CUBI

PymetricsMedium Risk

Assessment

Neuroscience-based assessments using games to measure cognitive and emotional traits, matched against successful employee profiles.

AI Features

  • Neuroscience-based games
  • Trait matching algorithms
  • Bias-tested models
  • Job-fit predictions

Applicable Laws

NYC Local Law 144Colorado AI Act

Compliance Requirements

RequirementHireVuePymetrics
NYC Bias Audit Required
Annual third-party audit under Local Law 144
Likely YesLikely Yes
Colorado Impact Assessment
Annual assessment for high-risk AI systems
RequiredLikely Required
Illinois Consent Required
AIVI/BIPA consent for video/biometric analysis
YesCheck Configuration
Candidate Notifications
Disclosure that AI is being used
RequiredRequired
Data Collected
Types of candidate data processed
  • Video recordings
  • Audio and speech patterns
  • Facial expressions
  • Text transcripts
  • Assessment scores
  • Behavioral data from games
  • Game performance data
  • Cognitive trait scores
  • Behavioral patterns

Key Compliance Considerations

HireVue

  • AEDT under NYC Local Law 144 - requires annual bias audit
  • Illinois AIVI consent required for video analysis
  • Colorado AI Act high-risk system notification required
  • Facial expression analysis may trigger additional biometric consent laws
  • Speech pattern analysis requires transparency disclosures

Pymetrics

  • AEDT requiring bias audit
  • High-risk AI system under Colorado AI Act
  • Trait analysis may raise fairness questions

Our Recommendation

Both Tools Require Compliance Attention

Pymetrics has a lower compliance burden, but both tools require attention to AI hiring regulations depending on how you use them.

Key steps for either tool:

  • Document how AI influences employment decisions
  • Implement candidate notification workflows
  • Schedule bias audits if using in NYC
  • Complete impact assessments for Colorado compliance

Need Help With Compliance?

EmployArmor helps you navigate compliance for any AI hiring tool you use.